Fri. Nov 20th, 2026

U.S. home insurers pocketed an estimated $113 billion in excess underwriting profit between 2021 and 2025, a new report from Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, the Revolving Door Project and Public Citizen charges. The study, titled "Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis," draws on National Association of Insurance Commissioners data and argues that climate impacts, reinsurance costs and construction prices cannot by themselves account for the steep rise in premiums. Also driving prices up, the authors say, are bloated overheads such as executive pay, advertising and shareholder dividends, plus record profits. At the same time, the report contends, carriers are aggressively denying and delaying claims, leaving homeowners without the protection they paid for, and it shows state by state how much climate adaptation work the industry's ill-gotten gains could fund.

The numbers tell the story, per the report. In 2025, insurers returned roughly 55 cents in claims for every premium dollar collected, down from 69 cents in 2021; in the 1990s, home insurance loss ratios averaged 74 percent. From 2021 through 2025, about 30% of claims were closed without payment, and of those that were paid, more than 22% took longer than 60 days. Rates kept climbing even where payouts fell: in Texas, premiums collected in 2025 were 78% higher than in 2021 while claims payouts dropped 23%, and Liberty Mutual's largest home insurance company in Texas raised rates by a cumulative 144% over the same stretch, with little objection from the state regulator. The report examines Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine and Florida, and estimates that an 80% minimum loss ratio, similar to federal rules for health insurers, would have cut underwriting income by about $113 billion from 2021 to 2025, money that could have stayed with homeowners and renters.

"Home insurers are simultaneously overcharging and short-changing households as the fossil fuel-driven climate crisis intensifies," said Kenny Stancil, deputy research director at the Revolving Door Project. He said relentless rate hikes and ever more denied claims have let companies generate billions in excess underwriting income, which they "waste on lavish CEO pay packages and endless ads" and funnel into financial markets to boost shareholder returns, and he urged public officials to use every tool to curb industry profiteering and redirect those gains toward helping communities adapt to more frequent and severe weather.

Elyse Schupak, policy advocate with Public Citizen's Climate Program, said insurers are maximizing profits by raising rates, withdrawing from communities and closing a staggering number of claims without payment. After years of pointing to climate change and rising disaster costs to justify offering policyholders less protection at a higher price, she said, the industry is reaping record profits, and while companies preach about protecting households, the numbers reveal the opposite.

Alex Martin, climate finance policy director at Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, said families are paying too much and getting less back when disasters strike, with 2025's 55 cents per premium dollar far below the historical average of 70 to 80 cents in the 1990s. Regulators and policymakers at every level, he said, should act now to stop families being forced to pay more for less.

The report also recommends tighter scrutiny of rate increases that accounts for loss ratio trends, requirements that insurers invest in and reward climate resilience, and greater transparency over underwriting, pricing and claim decisions.

Related Post